A failed tank: stop the water, then call
When a tank fails, the problem is rarely the heater alone. A 40 or 50 gallon tank can release its full volume plus the line pressure behind it, and the water will keep coming until the supply is closed. Close the cold valve above the heater first. If the valve will not turn, close the main shutoff where the water line enters the house.
Then cut power at the breaker for an electric unit or turn the gas valve to off for a gas unit. Soaked insulation and drywall dry faster when you start early, so towels and a wet vacuum help while you wait. A repair may still be possible, and the plumber confirms that on site, which is covered on the water heater repair page.
Choosing the replacement: tank, tankless or heat pump
| Option | Best fit | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Standard gas tank | Homes with an existing gas line and vent | Lower upfront cost, vent must be inspected |
| Standard electric tank | Homes without gas service | Simple install, slower recovery |
| Tankless | Households that want continuous hot water | Higher upfront cost, needs yearly descaling |
| Heat pump (hybrid) | Homes with open space around the unit | Needs clearance and a condensate drain |
Many homeowners choose a like-for-like swap in an emergency because it is the fastest path back to hot water. Changing fuel type or moving to tankless is a bigger job. It can be scheduled after the emergency is over, and tankless water heater service explains what that involves.
What the swap involves, step by step
- 01
Shut off and drain
Water, power or gas are isolated and the tank is drained to a floor drain or outdoors.
- 02
Remove the old unit
Lines, flue and relief piping are disconnected and the tank is taken away.
- 03
Set and connect
The new tank is leveled, lines are connected with new flex connectors and a relief valve line is run.
- 04
Test and explain
The plumber checks for leaks, vent draft or electrical load, and sets a safe temperature.
Tank down and water on the floor? Call for a licensed plumber, any hour.
Call (314) 461-6239Sizing and the permit question
Tank size is set by how many people shower in the morning, not by the square footage of the house. A two-person household often does fine with 40 gallons, while a family of five usually wants 50 or more. A plumber can read the label on the old tank and match or adjust it.
Permit rules differ from one St. Louis County city to the next, and we do not guess at them. Ballwin lists a Building Inspections Department at (636) 227-2129, and the city says occupied buildings must meet its housing code. Ask them before the work if you are selling the house.
What changes the price of a replacement
Cost factors we explain before work starts
- Tank size and fuelA 50 gallon gas unit and a 40 gallon electric unit are different products with different labor.
- Venting and gas pipingA gas unit may need a new vent connector or a sediment trap, and some older flues need correction.
- Code itemsAn expansion tank, a drain pan or a corrected relief line may be required to bring the install up to code.
- Access and haul-offBasement stairs and tight closets add labor. The old tank is hauled away.
- Time of dayEmergency and after-hours service is priced differently from a booked daytime visit.
Insurance often pays for the flood damage from a sudden tank failure but not the heater itself, so keep photos. Call (314) 461-6239 for your actual number.
Hard water and the life of your next heater
Missouri American Water reports total hardness of 66 to 226 ppm as calcium carbonate in its 2023 St. Louis County report, which is moderately hard to hard water. Scale shortens the life of any heater. An anode rod check every few years and a yearly flush are the simplest ways to stretch the next one, and a water softener reduces the load.
Standards note: The IPC also sets rules for relief valve discharge and, where required, drain pans, and we install to those rules. The City of Ballwin lists the International Plumbing Code among its adopted codes, and the Building Inspections Department at (636) 227-2129 can confirm which edition applies.
Water heater replacement questions from Ballwin homeowners
Yes. Call (314) 461-6239 and a licensed plumber is dispatched any hour for failed tanks and flooding. Same-day appointments are offered when a crew is free, and the price is given before the old tank is touched.
A like-for-like swap on an accessible unit is usually a half-day job. Changing fuel type, moving the unit or adding venting takes longer.
Often yes, but it needs a dedicated electrical circuit and the gas line must be capped safely. We explain the added work and cost before you decide.
Yes. The old tank is drained, disconnected and hauled away as part of the replacement.
Most tanks are on borrowed time after ten years. The date is coded in the serial number, and the plumber can read it for you.
Leave the house and call Spire at 1 (800) 887-4173 or 911 from outside. Do not light anything. We can start once the gas utility says the home is safe.
Water heater failed? Call the 24/7 line and get a licensed plumber scheduled.
Call (314) 461-6239